610-565-3701

Who Is Liable for a Car Accident on Private Property?

February 27, 2025
Media Car Accident Lawyers at Eckell Sparks Have the Experience You Need to Help You Pursue Fair Compensation in Your Car Accident Case

Car accidents can occur anywhere, including on private property. Determining liability in these cases can be more complicated because these accidents often involve parking lots, driveways, or other areas not subject to standard road regulations. Identifying who is responsible in such situations requires examining several factors, including property conditions, driver behavior, and any relevant local laws.

How Is Liability Determined for Accidents on Private Property?

Liability for car accidents on private property often centers on negligence. Drivers are required to operate their vehicles responsibly, regardless of whether they are on public roads or private property. Common factors that may affect liability include failing to obey posted signs, not yielding the right of way, or driving recklessly in areas with limited space or high pedestrian traffic.

The condition of the property may also influence liability. For example, if the property owner fails to maintain safe conditions, such as repairing potholes or clearly marking lanes, they might share responsibility for the accident. Determining liability involves reviewing police reports, security footage, witness statements, and the physical evidence at the scene.

What Happens if Both Drivers Share Responsibility?

In many cases, both drivers involved in an accident on private property share some degree of responsibility. For example, two drivers backing out of parking spaces simultaneously and colliding may each bear partial blame. In such situations, comparative negligence laws may apply. These laws allow fault to be distributed among the parties based on their percentage of responsibility.

Pennsylvania’s comparative negligence law dictates that recoverable damages can be adjusted to reflect a plaintiff’s percentage of fault. For example, if a court finds you 20% responsible, your damages will be reduced by that amount.

However, if you are found 50 or more percent at fault, you will not be entitled to compensation.

Can Property Owners Be Held Liable for Accidents?

Yes, if hazardous conditions on their property contributed to the accident. For example, poorly maintained surfaces, inadequate signage, or insufficient lighting can create unsafe conditions for drivers and pedestrians. Property owners are generally expected to take reasonable measures to maintain their premises and address any hazards that could lead to accidents. If a property owner fails to fulfill this responsibility, they could be found partially or fully liable for an accident.

Proving property owner liability may require documentation of the hazardous condition, such as photographs or maintenance records. You will also need evidence that the property owner was aware of the issue and did not address it in a timely manner.

What Role Do Insurance Policies Play in Private Property Accidents?

Insurance coverage can resolve liability for car accidents on private property. The at-fault driver’s insurance typically covers the damages, but that depends on the type of accident and the policies involved. In some cases, the property owner’s liability insurance may also come into play if their negligence contributed to the accident. For instance, if a poorly maintained parking lot causes a driver to lose control and crash, the property owner’s insurance might be responsible for covering part of the damages.

Understanding the details of the insurance policies involved, including any exclusions or limits, is important when seeking compensation.

How Can Drivers Protect Themselves After a Private Property Accident?

Drivers involved in accidents on private property can take steps to protect their rights and interests. These include:

  • Exchanging contact and insurance information with the other parties involved
  • Documenting the scene with photographs
  • Obtaining witness statements, if possible
  • Contacting law enforcement, as officers can create an official report that details the circumstances of the accident
  • Promptly notifying your insurance company about the accident is also important, as many policies have specific requirements for reporting incidents

Media Car Accident Lawyers at Eckell Sparks Have the Experience You Need to Help You Pursue Fair Compensation in Your Car Accident Case

Car accidents on private property can lead to serious injuries, property damage, and tricky legal implications. For a confidential consultation about your legal options, contact the experienced Media car accident lawyers at Eckell, Sparks, Levy, Auerbach, Monte, Sloane, Matthews & Auslander, P.C. Complete our online form or call our Media and West Chester, Pennsylvania, offices at 610-565-3701 for more information. We proudly serve clients in Delaware County, Chester County, and Montgomery County.