610-565-3700

Deer Collisions in Delaware County: Who Pays When You Hit a Deer or Swerve Into Another Car?

November 19, 2026
Deer Collisions in Delaware County: Who Pays When You Hit a Deer or Swerve Into Another Car?

Key Takeaways:

  • November is peak deer season on Delco’s wooded roads, especially at dawn and dusk after clocks fall back.
  • Hitting a deer is usually a “comprehensive” claim, while swerving into a car or tree is typically a “collision” claim.
  • A driver’s own first-party medical benefits pay initial medical bills regardless of fault.

When Delaware County car accident lawyers handle deer crash claims, they tell clients that comprehensive coverage usually pays for damage from hitting the deer. If a driver swerves into a tree or another car to avoid the deer, it typically becomes a collision claim. Another motorist may also share blame in these crashes: a driver who brakes for a deer and gets rear-ended by a tailgater may have a claim against that other motorist.

Why Are Deer Crashes So Common in Delaware County in November?

Deer crashes rise in November because the “rut,” or mating season, sends bucks chasing does across roads. Clocks also fall back, pushing evening commutes into dusk, when deer move most. Pennsylvania Department of Transportation (PennDOT) data revealed 6,309 deer-related crashes statewide in 2025, injuring 1,408 people; our Delaware County car accident lawyers often remind drivers to slow down near wooded stretches during these weeks.

Which Delco Roads See the Most Deer Activity?

Deer car accidents in Delaware County, PA, tend to happen on roads through wooded parklands: Route 3 (West Chester Pike) skirts Ridley Creek State Park, while Route 352 winds through the woods of Middletown and Edgmont townships. Farther southwest, Route 1 (Baltimore Pike) passes open land in Concord and Chadds Ford townships. Thick tree lines along these roads can hide deer until the last second. 

Does Car Insurance Cover Hitting a Deer in Pennsylvania?

Car insurance covers hitting a deer only if the policy includes “comprehensive coverage,” which Pennsylvania does not require. A driver with state-minimum liability coverage, for example, pays out of pocket to fix a crumpled hood. Even with comprehensive coverage, the “deductible,” or the set amount paid before insurance kicks in, still applies. For drivers who hit a deer, insurance in Pennsylvania also guarantees at least $5,000 in first-party medical benefits.

What Happens if a Driver Swerves to Miss a Deer and Hits Another Vehicle?

Any driver who swerves into another vehicle may be held at fault, depending on whether the reaction was reasonable. Picture a driver on Route 252 who jerks the wheel at dusk and clips an oncoming SUV. Insurers and courts would weigh that driver’s speed, distance, and whether braking came first. However, Pennsylvania’s Sudden Emergency Doctrine may also excuse a split-second choice made in a danger the driver did not create.

Can an Injured Person Bring a Claim Against Another Driver After a Deer-Related Crash?

Yes, if that driver’s carelessness, such as speeding or tailgating, helped cause the crash. When one driver swerves to avoid a deer, fault is split between the drivers by percentage, and anyone more than 50% at fault recovers nothing. If the insurance companies cannot settle, a Delaware County car accident lawyer can file a lawsuit at the Delaware County Courthouse in Media, where a jury assigns each driver’s share of fault and the amount of compensation.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs):

Is hitting a deer considered an at-fault accident in Pennsylvania?

Usually not. When a driver files a deer collision claim, PA insurers generally treat the strike as a not-at-fault loss, although each policy sets its own terms.

Who is liable if a driver swerves to avoid a deer and hits someone?

If the swerve was unreasonable, the swerving driver’s liability coverage typically pays for the other person’s injuries and vehicle damage.

Does a driver need to call the police after hitting a deer?

Pennsylvania law requires immediate police notice when someone is hurt, or a vehicle needs towing. Even when not required, a report provides written proof of what happened.

Our Skilled Delaware County Car Accident Lawyers at Eckell Sparks Untangle Fault After Deer-Related Crashes

To learn about your legal options after a crash like this, contact our Delaware County car accident lawyers at Eckell, Sparks, Levy, Auerbach, Monte, Sloane, Matthews & Auslander, P.C. To schedule an initial consultation, call us today at 610-565-3700 or complete our online form. With office locations in Media and West Chester, Pennsylvania, we proudly serve clients in the surrounding areas.